HOMELinksContact UsHelp

Judicial Evaluation of Sitting Judges
(Numbers represent the percentage of positive responses received)

2011 Results 2013 Results

2011 results for Jefferson District , U.S. District , U.S. Bankruptcy & Magistrate Judges

Judge

Judicial Temperament

Court Management

Judicial Integrity

Legal Ability

General Satisfaction

Jefferson District Court

 

 

 

 

 

Donald E. Armstrong Jr.

88

92

91

89

97

Stephanie Pearce Burke

91

93

92

91

89

Sean R. Delahanty

74

91

86

79

82

Annette C. Karem

62

76

73

55

55

Sandra L. McLaughlin

44

57

57

33

41

Jennifer B. Wilcox

95

98

97

93

95

Angela McCormick Bisig

87

89

89

81

86

Gina Kay Calvert

85

88

87

80

83

Anne Leitsch Haynie

93 93

93

92

94

Kathryn R. King 77 77 73 66 72
Ann Bailey Smith 95 97 95 96 95
Erica Lee Williams 90 90 91 82 89
David P. Bowles 93 95 96 91 94
Sheila A. Collins 77 89 87 76 78
David L. Holton II 96 96 97 90 96
Deana "Dee" McDonald 81 86 83 74 79

Michele B. Stengel

80

78

82

78

77

           

*Senior Status

 

 

 

 

 

Judith K. Bartholomew 88 93 93 86 88

Matthew K. Eckert

83 85 85 78 82
William P. Ryan Jr. 59 70 80 56 59
Kevin W. Delahanty 76 78 82 76 77
Paula Fitzgerald 48 38 75 28 28
Joan A. "Toni" Stringer 91 92 94 84 88
Deborah J. Deweese 85 89 93 83 85
Janice R. Martin 82 81 84 78 80
           

U.S. District Court

 

 

 

 

 

Jennifer B. Coffman

87

94

92

81

84

Charles R. Simpson III

85

84

89

78

83

John G. Heyburn II

92

97

93

88

93

Thomas B. Russell

94

97

99

92

95

 

 

 

 

 

 

U.S. Bankruptcy Court

 

 

 

 

 

Thomas H. Fulton

84

95

95

84

88

Joan A. Lloyd

89

92

93

92

92

 

 

 

 

 

 

Magistrate

 

 

 

 

 

James D. Moyer

96

97

98

96

97

Dave Whalin

89

96

96

90

93

For the complete 2011 Comparative Review, click here.

back to top

2013 Results for Jefferson Circuit & Family Court Judges

Judge

Judicial Temperament

Court Management

Judicial Integrity

Legal Ability

Overall Performance

Jefferson Circuit Court

 

 

 

 

 

Barry Willett 89

84

93

84

88

James M. Shake

96

96

96

92

96

Mitchell L. Perry

83

93

90

78

84

Charles L. Cunningham Jr.

92

98

96

89

95

Mary M. Shaw

95

92

97

81

93

Olu A. Stevens

74

88

81

65

69

Audra J. Eckerle

84

92

90

78

83

A.C. McKay Chauvin

86

95

92

86

90

Judith E. McDonald-Burkman

83

94

91

77

85

Brian C. Edwards

96

95

95

92

93

Susan Schultz Gibson

92

95

95

90

92

Frederic J. Cowan 74 75 91 65 70
           
*Senior Status          

Martin F. McDonald

36

59

55

31

33


Jefferson Family Court

 

 

 

 

 

Joan L. Byer

75

90

85

78

77

Hugh Smith Haynie

84

82

87

82

83

Patricia Walker FitzGerald

89

89

94

88

89

Dolly Wisman Berry

90

96

92

90

92

Eleanore M. Garber

78

83

89

78

78

Jerry J. Bowles

75

80

81

72

73

Joseph W. O'Reilly

60

74

81

64

57

Donna Delahanty

80

81

85

58

64

Stephen M. George

92

97

95

93

96

Paula F. Sherlock

82

85

87

72

79

For the complete 2013 Comparative Review, click here.

back to top

Copyright Louisville Bar Association. All rights reserved. Use of this Web site assumes acceptance of the Terms of Use.