HOMELinksContact UsHelp

Judicial Evaluation of Sitting Judges
(Numbers represent the percentage of positive responses received)

2005 Results 2004 Results

2005 results, for Jefferson Family Court and Jefferson District Court

Judge

Judicial Temperament

Court Management

Judicial Integrity

Legal Ability

Overall Performance

Jefferson Family Court

 

 

 

 

 

Dolly Wisman Berry

91

90

92

83

89

Jerry J. Bowles

84

89

87

82

84

Joan L. Byer

68

84

76

71

71

Patty Walker FitzGerald

94

89

95

88

90

Eleanore M. Garber

77

81

85

72

71

Kevin L. Garvey

74

93

92

80

81

Stephen M. George

96

98

97

97

98

Hugh Smith Haynie

90

90

92

87

91

Joseph W. O’Reilly

71

74

88

66

62

Paula F. Sherlock

85

85

88

77

79

 

 

 

 

 

Jefferson District Court

 

 

 

 

 

Donald E. Armstrong

89

95

91

89

90

Judith K. Bartholomew

92

94

95

88

90

Angela McCormick Bisig

87

89

87

82

84

Sheila A. Collins

87

93

89

87

87

Kevin W. Delahanty

84

89

89

85

89

Sean R. Delahanty

85

91

90

87

91

Deborah J. Deweese

84

88

87

84

83

Audra J. Eckerle

89

94

93

87

89

Jacquelyn P. Eckert

86

85

85

81

82

Matthew K. Eckert

80

90

83

83

82

Paula Fitzgerald

54

52

69

34

36

Anne Haynie

90

93

91

88

88

Janice R. Martin

88

89

90

86

88

Claude R. Prather

89

93

93

84

89

William P. Ryan, Jr.

78

92

89

73

81

Michele B. Stengel

86

86

85

78

81

Joan “Toni” Stringer

91

90

93

87

89

For the complete 2005 Comparative Review, click here.

back to top

2004 Results, for Jefferson Circuit, U.S. District, U.S. Bankruptcy & Magistrate Judge

Judge

Judicial Temperament

Court Management

Judicial Integrity

Legal Ability

Overall Performance

Jefferson Circuit Court

 

 

 

 

 

Lisabeth Hughes Abramson

89

97

95

85

88

Denise G. Clayton

91

87

92

76

82

F. Kenneth Conliffe

77

90

95

73

72

Martin F. McDonald

66

78

84

53

57

Judith McDonald-Burkman

91

94

95

84

87

Stephen K. Mershon

94

92

97

89

91

Geoffrey P. Morris

85

95

96

89

91

Stephen P. Ryan

77

88

90

75

80

Ann O’Malley Shake

91

93

93

87

89

James M. Shake

98

99

99

95

98

Barry L. Willett

81

83

95

73

74

Thomas B. Wine

86

95

92

82

83


U.S. District Court

 

 

 

 

 

Jennifer B. Coffman

80

86

93

73

83

John G. Heyburn II

89

94

95

89

89

Edward H. Johnstone

88

90

96

84

87

James D. Moyer

92

96

95

89

92

Thomas B. Russell

92

98

98

93

96

Charles R. Simpson

88

90

96

86

90


U.S. Bankruptcy Court

 

 

 

 

 

Joan L. Cooper

91

94

97

86

92

Thomas H. Fulton

93

98

99

95

91

David T. Stosberg

76

93

90

86

79

For the complete 2004 Comparative Review, click here.

back to top

Copyright Louisville Bar Association. All rights reserved. Use of this Web site assumes acceptance of the Terms of Use.